3 Comments
User's avatar
⭠ Return to thread
Elle Griffin's avatar

Right, it's kind of odd to think of the concept of "keeping the balance" when that balance is shifting all the time. At the same time, we know that metropolitan areas are liberal and rural areas are not, and Colin Woodward's cultural divides have remained relatively stable. I wonder if we could make one herculean effort to change state lines, and could then remain relatively stable in that new formation. I think the need for flexibility would help, but we also don't want to cause a big ruckus every year.

Expand full comment
Bryce Tolpen's avatar

I love how you incorporate Woodward‘s 11 nations into your analysis. I love his book (and Fischer’s Albion’s Seed before it). It’s like a good personality assessment: it gives us an objective and inoffensive way to talk about our differences.

Expand full comment
Elle Griffin's avatar

Right, it helps us understand that there are many cultures in America, and our past still has a bearing on our present and how we turned out.

Expand full comment